Mrs. Norris, Lady Bertram and pug, 2007 Mansfield Park"I hope she will not tease my poor pug," said Lady Bertram; "I have but just got Julia to leave it alone." - Mansfield Park, Chapter One
To the education of her daughters, Lady Bertram paid not the smallest attention. She had not time for such cares. She was a woman who spent her days in sitting nicely dressed on a sofa, doing some long piece of needlework, of little use and no beauty, thinking more of her pug than her children, but very indulgent to the latter, when it did not put herself to inconvenience, guided in every thing important by Sir Thomas, and in smaller concerns by her sister. – description of Lady Bertram by Jane Austen, Mansfield Park
One is continually struck by the varied roles that dogs have played (and continue to play) in civilized society. Take the Georgian era, for example. Dogs were either pampered and coddled in the upper echelons or considered a work dog at best or a pest in the lower stratas. The image of Lady Bertram caring more for her pug than children, and of the upper crust caring for their hunting dogs and appreciating their courage and companionship is reinforced by paintings commissioned at that time. Edwin Landseer, the famous Victorian painter of animals, painted a typical series of paintings for the day: Dogs in Low Places and High Places, which showed the dog in pampered and humble settings.
But for every coddled Georgian canine, there were a score of dogs that lived lives of misery as garbage collectors (scavenging what they could off the streets), or were used for cruel sports, such as dog fights or bear baiting. (I have deliberately used a small image, for I cannot think of the unspeakable cruelty such “sport” must have been to the animals.) Dog fights are still popular today, as evinced by the Michael Vick scandals.
Girl with her dog, British School, 1775, Sudley House
“Industrialization and urbanization in the late 18th and early 19th centuries shifted the focus of blood sports from baiting (in which dogs attacked other species) to fighting (in which dogs attacked each other). Rural laborers flocked to cities to become factory hands. They retained their love for blood sports but lacked the space and free days for baits of large animals. Dogfights, on the other hand, could be held indoors, artificial light allowed evening matches, and workers could still go to work the next day. Businesses called pits arose to meet the demand.” Edmund Russell, A Tale of Two Smithfields, UVA Today
Despite the cruel way in which dogs were treated, increased urbanization marked a change in which dogs were regarded. Edmund Russell goes on to say in his article, “At the same time, industrialization and urbanization in Britain changed attitudes toward dogs. Urbanites had little experience with raising farm animals for slaughter, while more and more families kept pets. Pet dogs had individual names, lived in the house, and never arrived for dinner on a platter.”
Portrait of an Extraordinary Musical Dog, Philip Reinagle, 1805, Virginia Museum of Fine Arts
Hunters were bred for specific purposes, and these dogs were kept in kennels to live lives of relative ease and prosperity.
Foxhounds and terriers in a kennel, John Emms (1843-1912)
But in an age when many people were displaced and lived in abject poverty, the last thing on their minds would be the well-being of their canine friends. During times of plague and epidemics, dogs were killed by the scores as potential carriers of diseases such as rabies. In her cookbook, Hannah Glasse provides recipes to make cures for those bitten by mad dogs. The first one is an 18th century recipe (1747) provided by a Dr. Mead.
As the 19th century progressed, humane societies were formed and paintings of dogs took on a sentimental turn, like this painting by Edwin Landseer entitled “Saved.” Today, the dog’s role in society has not changed much from what it was in Jane Austen’s day, and they still occupy a niche in all strata of society, from the high to the low … to the despicably cruel. (See image in this post.)
Edwin Landseer, Saved, 1856, Wikimedia Commons
For more about dogs in this era, click on the following links:
- Dr. Mead’s Mad Dog Recipe, Gentleman’s Magazine
Landseer High and Low images from Picturing Animals in Great Britain: 1750-1850
I just have to say thanks for writing this because I am kind of obsessed with the portrayal of dogs in 18th century art…or just dogs in the 18th century in general. So it’s good to know I’m not the only one writing about this subject! Not to plug myself, but I have a post about the popularity of pugs so I am totally amused that Austen even wrote about them.
There was an exhibition a few years back (which I missed, of course!) about the dog in art, and it has a great exhibition catalog which you might be aware of. Here is the <a href=”http://www.amazon.com/Best-Show-Dog-Renaissance-Today/dp/0300115881
to it on Amazon, and I even found a google book preview here!
Thank you, Heather. Frankly, you can plug your fabulous blog on mine any time!!
As always, another fascinating post. I finally got around to watching the recent film Marie Antoinette, and the dogs were certainly everywhere!
Great post! I read your blog almost everyday and love your articles. As a participant in dog shows, I found this one too interesting not to comment on! :)
anacrhonous91, thank you for leaving a comment. I am an avid dog lover and cannot abide man’s cruelty to his faithful friend. Bookchronicle, as always it is fabulous to read your comments.
Vic
Wow, this post is fantastic. I’m so glad that I stumbled into it. I am also a huge dog lover and some of the more commonly practiced abuses of our fair 4-pawed friends breaks my heart for those animals then as much as for the ones being mistreated today.
I did a post on my blog about dogs in post card art, which was really fun to research and write, so I hope that you had a good time writing this one too, despite some of the crueler evidence of how we treat our best friends.
Thanks for this super post.
His Landseer (dog in Saved painting) looks exactly like my Landseer. The painting brings tears to my eyes, because my Cleo was such a loving and caring animal towards everyone, especially the cats, hamsters and other small critters we had during her reign. She always knew when something wasn’t right and always defended the victim in a fight.
She died unfortunately of a twisted gut two years ago, yet has left behing such a void that I can’t bring myself to replace her…
Whoever breeds these dogs nowadays (not the Newfoundland Landeer, but the pure Landseer), is a breeder of angels…
I’m fascinated by all the reseach you have done. Have you by any chance come across references to the suggestion that pet dogs should be exercised or walked on a regular basis? I’m trying to find out when this came about.
Obviously working dogs got their exercise doing a job and most for many years never knew a lead attached to their collar.
I’ve found information from the early 19c Century regarding new laws in the Metropolitan District in London brought about due to the prevalance of rabies. The laws state that dogs not under the ‘control’ of any person could be apprehended by the Police. The interpretation of ‘control’ was subject to Court discretion, I haven’t researched any decisions on that yet.
If you have any information at all would you please email me directly, perhaps we can share research?
Many thanks. Jeanie
[…] The 19th Century Dog Occupying High and Low and, Yes, Even Cruel Places […]
[…] Jane Austen’s World and Regency Ramble both give comprehensive discussions on dogs of the early nineteenth century. […]