• Home
  • Audio/Podcasts
  • Austensites
  • AV/E-Texts
  • History
  • JA Novels & Bio
  • Links
  • Original Sources/19th C. Texts
  • Social Customs During the Regency
  • Teacher/Student
  • Writer/Literature Resources

Jane Austen's World

This Jane Austen blog brings Jane Austen, her novels, and the Regency Period alive through food, dress, social customs, and other 19th C. historical details related to this topic.

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« Return to Cranford: A Delight
How Helen Jerome’s ‘Pride and Prejudice: A Sentimental Comedy in Three Acts’ Ties in With Anna Massey, Mrs. Norris of Mansfield Park »

Review: Thoughts about ‘Return to Cranford’, or I’m just mad about Miss Matty

January 12, 2010 by Vic

I await each January with joy, knowing that PBS Masterpiece Classic will return. Two years ago PBS concentrated on Jane Austen; last year, two Jane Austen film adaptations were featured; and this year we get to see not only the new adaptation of Emma, but reruns of Persuasion and Northanger Abbey as well. Viewers are also treated to Return to Cranford, the sequel to Cranford, last year’s runaway BBC and PBS hit. Reprising their recurring roles are the stellar actors who represent Cranford’s spinsters and widows and other denizens of this quaint Victorian town. And then we are treated to new characters, each with stories of their own.

Even as I reveled in watching the first new installment of this sequel, I found some of the new stories a tad too familiar and I could not help but shake off a vague sense of disappointment. This feeling was similar to having visited a new vacation spot for the first time. You and your family love the experience so much, you eagerly plan a return. But during the second trip , you feel a slight let down. The wonder and discovery are gone, replaced with  a sense of déjà vu and sameness. You find yourself going over old ground and repeating excursions that somehow don’t seem quite as satisfying as last time.

And so it is with Return of Cranford. All the elements of the original Cranford are still there – the Victorian town ruled by the rigid principles that are followed by a group of widows and spinsters who are set in their old-fashioned ways. The railroad still threatens the town’s placid existence, and the only person barring the line’s completion is Lady Ludlow, whose stubborn resistance is misplaced.

Francesca Annis, pale, gray and achingly beautiful, makes a short but memorable entrance and exit, as does handsome Greg Wise as Sir Charles Maulver, and Claudie Blakley as Martha, Miss Matty’s maid of all work.

New characters replace the old ones who have (sadly) moved on. The viewer is still treated to a story about star-crossed lovers (Tom Hiddleston as William Buxton and Jody Whittaker as Peggy Bell),  and an implacable father (Jonathan Pryce as Mr. Buxton) who stands in the way of their happiness. They must somehow overcome all obstacles to remain together. Part of the mystery of Return to Cranford is how they will achieve this.

Return to Cranford relies heavily on Judi Dench’s Miss Matty to keep the story threads together. While she was a pivotal character in Cranford, it was her sister Miss Deborah Jenkyns (Eileen Atkins), who was the backbone of Cranford’s widow and spinster society. Miss Deborah inspired steadfast loyalty to her unwavering convictions; Miss Matty, on the other hand, is much softer in character and a person that others want to protect. She has had to grow a strong backbone after her sister’s death, but she is still too easy a touch and has difficulty holding the small band of ‘The Amazons’ together. When hoity toity Mrs. Jamieson’s (Barbara Flynn’s) sister-in-law Lady Glenmire (Celia Imrie) comes to visit, Miss Matty and her cohort are given the sort of social snubbing that Miss Deborah would not have brooked for an instant.

Don’t get me wrong. I am still mad about Miss Matty, who is portrayed by the incomparable Judi Dench. And though her character is too weak to rule the town with the iron fist that her sister Deborah used, she’s become the town’s morally upright compass.

One of the main problems I found with episode one of Return to Cranford is the lack of real tension in the plot. This might be due to the fact that this adaptation was written largely by Heidi Thomas, not by master story teller Elizabeth Gaskell.  A dastardly character is introduced by way of Lady Ludlow’s wastrel son, Septimus (Rory Kinnear), but he is merely an unfeeling cad and shows up only long enough in the film to prove to us that Lady Ludlow had wasted her motherly affection (and money) on an unworthy son. His actions do not produce the tight-as-a-drum-tension that compels a viewer to keep watching a show or a reader to keep turning the pages. The train trip, in which Miss Matty convinces her friends to give the railroad a chance, does not provide much tension either, and the central love story between Peggy Bell and William Buxton seems like something that we have seen before.

Much of the quirky humor I delighted in with the first film is gone, although it was fun to see the ladies get tipsy as they warmed towards Lady Glenmire, and to see Miss Pole get her comeuppance as she makes a bird cage out of a French petticoat hoop frame for her parrot.

Episode Two gets much better. There’s real tension between Mr. Buxton and his son after William declares his love for Peggy Bell. Rather than honor his father’s wishes to find a more suitable wife, William decides to remain true to Peggy, make his own way in the world and work for the railroad until he has enough money to marry her.  The ladies of Cranford provide a funny backdrop to Lady Glenmire’s romance with Captain Brown. And we follow the fortunes of young Harry, who is torn between two worlds. He does not belong at boarding school and has good reasons for running away. A train accident, which kills poor Mrs Forrester’s cow and puts Harry’s life in danger, provides some true heart-wrenching moments. But all’s well that ends well. Miss Matty finds a satisfying way to unify the town, and the magic act of Senor Brunoni (Tim Curry in a funny role) was a fine (and wonderful) way to end the show and tie up loose story ends.

A friend who watched the show with me (and who did not see Cranford last year), found Return to Cranford delightful. So, I shall attribute my churlishness to a jaded palate and concede that Return is a delightful show, one worthy of viewing and certainly better than anything the competition on commercial television and cable tv have to offer. While my ranking of Cranford was five out of five stars, I rate this sequel a tad lower: four out of five stars.

  • Missed the first episode? Watch it online until Februay 16th
  • Cranford’s new characters
  • Poll on Jane Austen Today: Vote on what you thought of the first episode
  • Austenprose’s recap and review
  • Cranford Under the Bonnet
  • For more links about Return to Cranford, click on the post below

Share with others:

  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in jane austen, Movie review, Regency Life, Regency World, Victorian Era | Tagged Elizabeth Gaskell, PBS Masterpiece Classic, PBS Movie Adaptation, Return to Cranford | 13 Comments

13 Responses

  1. on January 12, 2010 at 01:34 Charleybrown

    Vic, I have to agree with what you said! Granted, I will rewatch this sequel if given a chance in the future but it just didn’t bowl me over like the original series did. There were moments throughout that reminded me of why I fell in love with ‘Cranford’ but it didn’t sweep me up like last time.
    -Reluctantly Jaded :)


  2. on January 12, 2010 at 02:13 Kimberly

    Thanks for the review! I love Cranford and Mrs. Gaskell’s books. I will check this out.


  3. on January 12, 2010 at 02:23 Return to Cranford for Bustling Bonnets and a Bit of Melodrama – Recap and Review « Austenprose

    […] Thoughts about R2C on Jane Austen’s World […]


  4. on January 12, 2010 at 09:40 Rachel

    Maybe it will get better with the second half!

    I have to admit that I don’t remember so many characters dying off in the book! I’ll have to go back and read the last book of the Cranford chronicles.


  5. on January 12, 2010 at 09:47 Sue Wilkes

    I have to agree with Vic’s comments – I enjoyed it, but there was something missing. My favourite Gaskell adaptation is still the BBC’s version of Wives and Daughters.


  6. on January 16, 2010 at 18:53 Joanne

    I, like your friend, did not see the first series, although I read the book last year. Once I figured out who was whom, and that the story picks up where the book leaves off, I thoroughly enjoyed it.

    Lack of tension, yes. Ho-hum, yes. But I too caught up in the scenery and costumes to notice!


  7. on January 18, 2010 at 08:06 Return to Cranford: A Delight « Jane Austen's World

    […] episode of Return to Cranford provided some humor, much pathos and sadness, and new beginnings. (My review sits here.) What did you think of this episode? Leave a comment or vote on Jane Austen Today. Missed the […]


  8. on January 18, 2010 at 17:00 Laura Brodian Freas

    “Lack of tension,” you say? I should have thought that the train wreck and its concommitent griefs ought to have been tension enough.


    • on January 18, 2010 at 17:59 Vic

      Laura, You are absolutely right about the second episode, which picked up immensely. I meant to attach an addendum saying that the story lines came together in Part II, ending the story in a most satisfying way.


  9. on January 18, 2010 at 22:26 Eric3000

    Good review, Vic. It was fun but it can’t compare to the first series. The first one seemed to unfold much more slowly so you could savor small details, while this one somehow seemed rushed, like they were just trying to fit a bunch of plots in. That is partly due to the fact that the first series must have been longer. Still, there were some good moments and it was enjoyable.


  10. on March 4, 2010 at 13:50 Deborah Boller

    I loved every minute of “Cranford.” I own the DVD and watch it more than is probably healthy! But “Return to Cranford” made caricatures of the returning characters and tried too hard to create dramatic situations. (For example, what was the point of Martha dying? When Miss Deborah died, it provided the chance for Miss Matty to grow as a person and stop living in Deborah’s shadow. And if Mr Holbrook hadn’t died, the situation of Miss Matty’s finances would not have come up. But Martha’s death did nothing for the story and killed off a really wonderful character.) So much of the charm and brilliance of “Cranford” was dealing with everyday situations that were big in the eyes of the community. The sequel is really not worth watching. The writers (whom I admire very much; I enjoy the movie better than the book, I’m almost ashamed to say) would have done much better to get the actors they wanted and make a new series.


  11. on August 8, 2010 at 12:27 Sasheeeeee

    I loved Return to Cranford, and being an avid Cranford follower, I was disappointed that Return to Cranford ending :(
    When Tilly came out of the magic box, I cried, and yet ANOTHER cry moment was when Harry bought the new calf.
    I advise them BBC strongly to make another Cranford, and all followers shall watch with avid suspense! I was also very disappointed with the choice of Miss Matty’s brother, as the previous actor was more suited to the part. Sad, sad.
    I <3 Harry Gregson, whose character had a huge amount of symbolism, and who spoke to all those who lack opportunity. The second season ended quite quickly with Miss Matty's happiness coming so quickly at the very end, and left no time for viewers to savour the experience. Still, all in all, 5 out of 5 for amazing actors, good plot, wonderful dialogue and characters that keep tears in your eyes until the very end. :)


  12. on November 7, 2010 at 11:41 The Cranford Companion: A Review « Jane Austen's World

    […] Thoughts about ‘Return to Cranford’ or I’m Just Mad About Miss Maddie […]



Comments are closed.

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 7,003 other followers

  • Items of Interest

    Black London by Gretchen Gerzina

    Free E-Book: Gerzina has written a fascinating account of London blacks, focusing on the late 18th and early 19th centuries. Because of a paucity of sources from blacks themselves, Gerzina had to rely primarily on glimpses through white eyes, especially those of antislavery advocate Granville Sharp. Gerzina is quite adept at culling evidence of a rich, complex black life, with significant interaction (and intermarriage) with the white community. Although subjected to much discrimination, London blacks never suffered as much as their American counterparts. The author rightly concludes that blacks have played an important role in the life of London for much of its history.

    Click on this link to Dartmouth.edu.

    Book cover of Black London

    And

    Perfect for Easter: Rachel Dodge's The Little Women Devotional, published March 2022. 

    This book has a devotional entry for every chapter of Little Women by Louisa May Alcott. You can read a chapter of Little Women and then read the corresponding devotional entry, going through the book one chapter at a time.

    Book Cover Little women devotional Dodge 2022

    Order the book: Amazon link

    Note: Rachel Dodge is a monthly contributor to this blog.

  • Follow Jane Austen's World on WordPress.com
  • Blog Stats

    • 15,994,974 hits
  • Highly Recommended a New Book! Bath -An Adumbration in Rhyme

  • Edited by Ben Wiebracht. Read the review of the book at this link. Click to order the book on Amazon US or Amazon UK

  • Book cover of Bath: An Adumbration in Rhyme by John Matthews
  • In Sri Lanka lies the grave of Rear Admiral Charles Austen CB, Jane Austen’s Brother

    The neglected tombstone found in an overgrown burial ground.

    Rear Admiral Charles Austen CB

    Died off Prome, the 7th October 1852, while in command of the Naval Expedition on the river Irrawady against the Burmese Forces, aged 73 years.”

    The grave after restoration

    Read the full article in The Sunday Times. June 27, 2021.

  • The Obituary of Charlotte Collins by Andrew Capes

    Click on image to read the story.

  • Comments

    “My idea of good company…is the company of clever, well-informed people, who have a great deal of conversation.” – Jane Austen, Persuasion

     

    Gentle readers: Please feel free to post your comments and continue the conversation! Due to SPAM, we will no longer accept comments on posts after 30 days of publication. In some instances, links will be removed from comments as well.

  • Administrators and Contributors

    Vic Sanborn, founder of this blog, is supported by a team of talented and knowledgeable writers about Jane Austen and the Regency era. They are:

    • Brenda Cox
    • Rachel Dodge and
    • Tony Grant, who now contributes his photos from London and England

    Click on their names to enter their own blogs.

    In addition, we thank the many experts and authors who frequently contribute their posts and opinions, and who continue to do so freely or at our request.

  • Pin It!

    Follow Me on Pinterest
  • Top Posts

    • Highclere Castle Floor Plan: The Real Downton Abbey
      Highclere Castle Floor Plan: The Real Downton Abbey
    • Social Customs During the Regency
      Social Customs During the Regency
    • The Servant's Quarters in 19th Century Country Houses Like Downton Abbey
      The Servant's Quarters in 19th Century Country Houses Like Downton Abbey
    • Regency Fashion: Men's Breeches, Pantaloons, and Trousers
      Regency Fashion: Men's Breeches, Pantaloons, and Trousers
    • Men's hair styles at the turn of the 19th century
      Men's hair styles at the turn of the 19th century
    • Regency Hygiene: The Bourdaloue
      Regency Hygiene: The Bourdaloue
    • Edward Cooper: Jane Austen’s Evangelical Cousin, Part 2
      Edward Cooper: Jane Austen’s Evangelical Cousin, Part 2
    • Setting a Broken Bone: 19th century medical treatment was not for sissies
      Setting a Broken Bone: 19th century medical treatment was not for sissies
    • Upstairs in Downton Abbey: The Three Crawley Sisters
      Upstairs in Downton Abbey: The Three Crawley Sisters
    • Regency Hairstyles and their Accessories
      Regency Hairstyles and their Accessories
  • Recent Posts

    • Edward Cooper: Jane Austen’s Evangelical Cousin, Part 2
    • Sanditon, Season 2, Episode 1: A Belated Review
    • Sense & Sensibility: Review of a play by Kate Hamill
    • ‘You Sink Your Voice’: The Subtle Art of Listening in Persuasion
    • Happy 1st Day of May (and its traditions)
  • Links to Jane Austen Blogs

    Click here to enter the page. Topics include Regency fashion, historic foods, Jane Austen societies, British sites, related topics. Click on image.

  • Find Jane Austen on Google

  • May we suggest?

    Regent’s Canal Walk (Little Venice to Kings Cross): Tony Grant

    Canal opposite Masefield House-TonyGrant

    Take a walk along a portion of Regent’s Canal with Tony Grant and friend. His superb photos and commentary make you feel as if you’ve tagged along.

    John Masefield House

    Click on this link to stroll along with Tony & Guy. (Images: Barges along Regent’s Canal; John Masefield’s House. Copyright: Tony Grant)

    Also recommended:

    The following Audible book/Kindle book:

    A Visitor’s Guide to Jane Austen’s England by Sue Wilkes. Read a preview of the book on Amazon. I’ve enjoyed listening to this informative and entertaining book on long rides and reading it while waiting at the doctor’s, or dentist’s, or when dining alone at restaurants.

  • Hello, my name is Vic and I live in Maryland, USA. I have adored Jane Austen almost all of my life. I am a proud lifetime member of the Jane Austen Society of North America. This blog is a personal blog written and edited by me and my team. We do not accept any form of cash advertising, sponsorship, or paid topic insertions. However, we do accept and keep books and CDs to review.

    If you would like to share a new site, or point out an error, please email us. (Yes, we are fallible. We'll own up to our mistakes and will make the corrections with a polite smile on our faces.) Write us at

    gmailbw

    Thank you for visiting this blog. Your comments and suggestions are most welcome.

  • Coming March 1, 2022

    Katherine Cowley’s second mystery in her Mary Bennet mystery series, The True Confessions of a London Spy, will be available in stores everywhere on March 1, 2022.

    Available March 1, 2022.

    Digital:

    • Amazon Kindle
    • Amazon Kindle UK

     

  • Top Posts & Pages

    • Highclere Castle Floor Plan: The Real Downton Abbey
    • Social Customs During the Regency
    • The Servant's Quarters in 19th Century Country Houses Like Downton Abbey
    • Regency Fashion: Men's Breeches, Pantaloons, and Trousers
    • Men's hair styles at the turn of the 19th century
    • Regency Hygiene: The Bourdaloue
    • Edward Cooper: Jane Austen’s Evangelical Cousin, Part 2
    • Setting a Broken Bone: 19th century medical treatment was not for sissies
    • Upstairs in Downton Abbey: The Three Crawley Sisters
    • Regency Hairstyles and their Accessories
  • Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape
  • Disclaimer: Our team makes no profit from this blog. We may receive books (physical or digitized) and DVDs for review purposes.

  • Copyright Statement: © Jane Austen's World blog, 2009-2022. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owners is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Jane Austen's World with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

Blog at WordPress.com.

WPThemes.


  • Follow Following
    • Jane Austen's World
    • Join 7,003 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Jane Austen's World
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
    %d bloggers like this: